Alphabet Shareholder Sues Pichai, Page, Brin and Board Over AI Training on Pirated Data and Voiceprints, Complaint Alleges
Bot Mutiny |
Summary
A shareholder filed a derivative suit on November 11, 2026 accusing 13 Alphabet directors and officers of an unlawful strategy of training AI on pirated datasets and collecting voiceprints. The claims are unproven allegations.
An Alphabet shareholder filed a derivative lawsuit on November 11, 2026, accusing Alphabet's chief executive and board of adopting "an unlawful business strategy" of using copyrighted works and people's voiceprints to build Google's AI products. The verified stockholder derivative complaint, Rosen v. Pichai, was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division, by shareholder Phil Rosen. It names 13 directors and officers, including Sundar Pichai, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, with Alphabet as a nominal defendant. The claims are allegations by the plaintiff, and the filing contains no response from the defendants.
What the complaint alleges
The complaint says Alphabet and Google trained their large language models and text-to-image models on "multiple pirated datasets," naming Z-Library, the LAION-400M and LAION-5B datasets, and the img2dataset tool, and says sound recordings, musical compositions and lyrics were taken from YouTube and Magenta. It lists the affected models as including Bard, Gemini, Imagen, Imagen 2, Lyria, Lyria 2, Lyria 3, MuLan and MusicLM. On Imagen, the complaint says Google announced the model in May 2022 and conceded it had trained it on the LAION-400M dataset.
A second set of allegations concerns voice data. The complaint says Alphabet distributes commercial voice models through Gemini Live, NotebookLM Audio Overviews, YouTube auto-dubbing, Google Cloud Text-to-Speech and Google Assistant "on more than a billion devices." It alleges the company ingested "hundreds of thousands of hours of human speech recordings" and extracted the speakers' voiceprints. The complaint says the defendants failed to identify the source speakers, provide written notice of the specific purpose and duration of collection, or obtain a written release from each speaker, in violation of the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act.
The complaint says the defendants followed an "ask forgiveness not approval" model rather than using a clean dataset, and describes that conduct as bad faith.
The related lawsuits it cites
The complaint says the defendants were on notice of the legal risk. It lists existing cases against Alphabet and Google, including Leovy v. Google, filed July 11, 2023, and Zhang v. Google, filed April 26, 2024, which were consolidated as In re Google Generative AI Copyright Litigation. It also cites Kogon v. Google, a class action by copyright holders and musicians filed March 6, 2026, in the Northern District of Illinois.
It points to earlier biometric cases as well, saying Rivera v. Google settled for $100 million and that class actions on behalf of school children whose voices and faces were used on Google's AI platform settled for $8.75 million. And it cites litigation against other AI developers, saying Anthropic paid $1.5 billion to resolve the first Concord Music Group case and faces additional damages of up to $3 billion in a second one.
Claims and relief sought
Because it is a derivative suit, the shareholder sues on Alphabet's behalf, and any money recovered would go to the company. The prayer for relief asks the court to declare that the defendants breached their fiduciary duties and that the director defendants violated Section 14(a) of the Securities Exchange Act and SEC Rule 14a-9. It also seeks damages for Alphabet, restitution and disgorgement, and governance changes, including "effective oversight of compliance with copyright and BIPA laws." The plaintiff demands a jury trial.
The complaint says Alphabet's directors and officers collectively hold 54.3% of the voting power of its common stock, and that Page holds 27.4% and Brin 25.3%.
What is not established
Nothing in the complaint has been tested in court. Rosen writes that his allegations rest on personal knowledge only as to himself and his own acts, and otherwise on information and belief from his counsel's investigation. He also says he "believes that substantial additional evidentiary support will exist for the allegations set forth herein after a reasonable opportunity for discovery." The filing reviewed here includes no answer or motion from Alphabet or the individual defendants.