New York City Council Passes Surveillance Pricing Ban 44-5, With Fines of Up to $1,000 Per Violation, The Record Reports
Bot Mutiny |
Summary
The New York City Council voted 44-5 to bar businesses from using personal data to set different prices for different customers, The Record reported. The bill would allow fines of up to $1,000 per violation.
The New York City Council voted 44-5 on Thursday, November 12, 2026, to approve a bill that bars retailers and other businesses from using surveillance pricing, the practice of using customers' personal data to charge different people different amounts for the same product, The Record reported. New York becomes the second US city to pass such a ban, after Seattle, where a similar measure was signed into law last month, according to the outlet.
What the bill does
Under the bill, the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection could fine companies that deploy surveillance pricing up to $1,000 for each violation. The bill carves out "bona fide discounts and rewards that are legitimate and transparent, from buy-one-get-one-free deals and loyalty programs to discounts for veterans and students," according to a City Council press release quoted by The Record.
Mayor Zohran Mamdani celebrated the vote. "When corporations use your personal data to decide what you pay, you only stand to lose," he told the media, as quoted by The Record.
Grace Gedye, a Consumer Reports policy analyst who worked on the effort, said that once the bill becomes law and takes effect, "it will mean eight million fewer people will have to guess about whether their search history, what they are hovering over online, and more, is shaping the price they see." She added that businesses already required to change their practices for New York City "may decide to do it for the rest of the country at the same time."
The state bill and other jurisdictions
Gedye noted that the New York state legislature passed a similar surveillance pricing law in June, but that the bill has been sitting unsigned on Gov. Kathy Hochul's desk for several months, according to The Record. Advocates worry that even if Hochul signs it, she could use an unusual New York statute that lets governors unilaterally amend passed bills to weaken its language.
George Slover, senior counsel for competition policy at the Center for Democracy and Technology, said New Jersey, Connecticut and Maryland already have similar bans on the books and that many more state legislators are expected to introduce bills when sessions begin early next year. "There is a lot of interest around the country in this issue," he told the outlet.
What the evidence shows so far
The Record wrote that public evidence of surveillance pricing is limited, even though grocery stores, ride sharing companies and airlines are thought to use it widely. It pointed to several earlier developments.
In October, the Federal Trade Commission ordered nine food delivery, airline, ride-sharing and retail companies to answer extensive questions about how they use personal data to set higher prices for some consumers and lower compensation for some workers. The recipients include major airlines, Uber, DoorDash, Walmart and Target, The Record reported.
In 2022, Target paid $5 million to settle a lawsuit brought by several California district attorneys who alleged the company showed customers standing in its parking lot lower prices than those shown in store, the outlet reported, linking to Associated Press coverage. Last year, SFGate reported that changing a web browser's location produced lower prices for the same New York City hotel rooms for customers in the Midwest and Phoenix than for customers in San Francisco.
Advocates have long charged that the grocery chain Kroger uses surveillance pricing, a charge the company has, in The Record's words, "steadfastly denied." Consumer Reports has reported that Kroger tracks shoppers' purchases and behavior and sells the data to third parties for targeted advertising. Kroger has confirmed it uses digital price tags to change prices quickly, though it has said changes are not made based on personal data, according to The Record.
What is not yet established
The Record's report does not say when the bill would take effect or whether the mayor has signed it. It also does not identify any business that has been found to use surveillance pricing in New York City. The Record describes "widespread suspicion" that consumers are charged varying amounts based on algorithms, but says public evidence of surveillance pricing is limited and that lawmakers and regulators are acting anyway.