NHS England Deletes Claim 137 Trusts Benefit From Palantir Data Platform, Guardian Reports
Bot Mutiny |
Summary
The Guardian reports that NHS England has deleted a web claim that 137 hospital trusts benefit from Palantir's data platform, after 29 trusts said they were not using all or most of it. NHS England did not respond to requests for comment.
The Guardian reported on 12 November 2026 that NHS England has deleted a claim from its website stating that 137 hospital trusts are benefiting from Palantir's federated data platform, known as the FDP. In an exclusive, the newspaper said the list appears to have been taken down after its earlier reporting that 29 of those trusts were not using all or most of the system. NHS England did not respond to the Guardian's requests for comment. We covered the original findings in our earlier report.
What was removed
According to the Guardian, health bosses had published a list of all the NHS bodies "live" with and "realising benefits" from the FDP, a system set up to improve patient outcomes, boost operating theatre efficiency and speed up bed discharges. After 29 trusts said the system was either not live or that they were not using any of its applications, the Guardian said the original list of hospitals appears to have been taken down.
The newspaper said a less detailed page now says early users were "already seeing real results", and describes reduced admin, faster patient pathways and more time for care.
Scrutiny of NHS England's claims
The Guardian said the move comes as ministers weigh whether to extend Palantir's £330m contract to 2029, and after the Office for Statistics Regulation said it was examining the NHS claims about the extent of the system's use. The paper reported that critics say the claims make the platform appear more embedded in the health service than it is. It also said NHS England was previously warned by the regulator that it has no evidence to support a claim that the technology has helped deliver more than 100,000 extra operations.
The Guardian said the decision to remove the list followed research by the Medact campaign group, which sent freedom of information requests to every hospital and integrated care board in England.
Reaction
Ben Coleman, a Labour MP and member of the Commons health and social care select committee, said it was "troubling" that NHS England had listed the 137 trusts as benefiting from the FDP, but then "apparently pulled the list when 29 said they weren't using all or most of it".
"When NHS England makes claims like this without checking them, it destroys trust," Coleman said. He added: "This latest overclaim could put more hospitals off using the FDP and threaten its viability." The Guardian said he wants the NHS to drop Palantir and develop an open platform on which trusts and British technology companies can build tools.
Rhiannon Mihranian Osborne, an NHS doctor and Medact spokesperson, said: "It's a relief to see these webpages taken down, but this has only happened after multiple investigations exposed the misleading nature of NHS England's claims." She also asked why NHS England had spent years using what she called shaky evidence to promote the alleged benefits of Palantir software, the Guardian reported.
Lobbying and the contract decision
It was reported last week that ministers planned to extend Palantir's deal amid intense lobbying, the Guardian said. It said Palantir has hired the Labour peer Tom Watson as a full-time lobbyist, and that he recently wrote to the health secretary, Yvette Cooper, saying Palantir wanted to help "build Britain's sovereign technological capability".
The union Unison has called on ministers to end the contract, and its general secretary, Andrea Egan, told the Guardian that any decision to extend the deal would be "completely unacceptable and a betrayal of staff and patients". Palantir has said ending its contract would be "putting politics above patients", according to the Guardian.
The Guardian said several groups, including the Doctors Association UK, Medact, Amnesty UK and Just Treatment, wrote this week to the prime minister, Andy Burnham, and to Cooper opposing a reported plan to give Palantir a further two years while the NHS transitions to UK-based technology. The groups said the deal could be safely ended in 2027 using a contract provision called the "termination assistance period".
What is not established
The Guardian's report says the list "appears" to have been taken down, and NHS England did not respond to the Guardian's requests for comment. The Guardian said the Office for Statistics Regulation was examining the NHS claims about the extent of the system's use, and that ministers were weighing whether to extend Palantir's contract.