Unsealed New York Times Filing Quotes Microsoft and OpenAI Staff on a "Doom Loop"
Bot Mutiny |
Summary
404 Media reports that an unsealed New York Times summary-judgment filing quotes Microsoft and OpenAI documents and testimony, including a Microsoft document describing a "doom loop" for its content suppliers and the web. The quotes are the plaintiffs' selection, as reported.
A summary-judgment filing in the New York Times copyright case against OpenAI and Microsoft was unsealed on September 17, 2026, according to 404 Media. The filing was written by lawyers for the New York Times. It collects statements from Microsoft and OpenAI documents and depositions that had been sealed or redacted at the defendants' request. The quotes below are the plaintiffs' selection, as reported by 404 Media. 404 Media does not report any court finding on them, and this summary relies on that reporting.
The "Doom Loop" Document
404 Media reports that the filing cites an internal Microsoft document saying the company's AI content strategy has started a "doom loop" that will hurt the performance of its models and the entire web. The document calls it highly unusual for an end product to threaten the economic foundations of its essential suppliers. 404 Media describes the document as finding that AI products cannibalize clicks from the sites they draw on. That description is the outlet's, not a quotation from the document.
An internal Microsoft document cited in the case, as quoted by 404 Media, says millions of people will soon consider large models "hoovering up" their work to be "an astonishing theft of unprecedented proportions." That is a statement about how the public is expected to react. It is not a statement that the practice is unlawful.
Testimony on Traffic
404 Media reports that Microsoft executives, including CEO Satya Nadella, testified under oath that clicks to news sites on Bing fell by more than 90 percent after content from the New York Times and other news sites was used. An OpenAI software engineer testified that "no matter how prominently we show the links, users won't click."
Other Quoted Material
According to 404 Media, documents obtained in the proceedings show an OpenAI reference to a method of getting around the New York Times paywall, and that OpenAI cofounder Greg Brockman replied "ah, nice." Microsoft executive Brent Hecht wrote that large models take content without ways of distributing economic value back down the supply chain, which threatens the economic stability of the people who create it. OpenAI policy director Jack Clark wrote that the company was creating systems that substitute for the labor of the people who define the culture of society. The report also says OpenAI called itself an "existential threat" to news publishers.
The Defendants' Position
404 Media notes that OpenAI's and Microsoft's lawyers have argued that their model training is fair use and transformative under copyright law. The report quotes no response from either company to the filing.
What This Does Not Establish
The filing is one party's argument and its choice of evidence. It does not show how a court will rule on fair use. The statements were made in internal documents and depositions, and they reach this article through plaintiffs' counsel and a news outlet. This summary relies on 404 Media's reporting and not on a reading of the full filing. Earlier versions of this article described the statements as admissions of theft and stated the plaintiffs' framing as fact. That has been corrected.