Meta Sues California Attorney General Bonta Over AB 1709 Ban on Personalized Feeds and Autoplay for Under-16s
Bot Mutiny |
Summary
Meta sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta on November 4, 2026 to block AB 1709, which would ban personalized feeds and autoplay for users under 16. This is what the complaint says.
Meta Platforms sued California Attorney General Rob Bonta in federal court on November 4, 2026, asking a judge to block a new state law that bans personalized feeds and autoplay for users under 16 on Facebook, Instagram and Threads. The complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, challenges Assembly Bill 1709, which takes effect January 1, 2027. Meta asks the court to declare key provisions of the law, including the personalized-feed ban, the autoplay ban and the account-deletion requirement, unlawful as applied to its three services and to bar Bonta from enforcing them against the company. The filing is Meta's account of the case and contains no response from the Attorney General.
What AB 1709 requires
According to the complaint, the California Legislature passed AB 1709 on August 31, 2026, and Governor Gavin Newsom signed it on September 10, 2026. The law regulates "covered platforms" that offer a covered feature (personalized feeds or autoplay) "as a significant part of the service provided." As signed, it names two covered features: feeds that include personalized content recommendations, and autoplay. The complaint says the Attorney General can also adopt regulations adding other features, and that none had been adopted when Meta filed.
The complaint describes three main obligations. Covered services may not provide covered features to anyone under 16 and must take "reasonable measures" to make sure minors are not given them. Services must delete the account of a user under 16 unless that user can keep an account with no covered features. And services may not provide covered features to a user of any age unless they use an age verification system, relying where available on age-bracket signals from app stores under California's Digital Age Assurance Act.
Enforcement belongs to the Attorney General and local public prosecutors. The complaint says the law threatens civil penalties of up to $50,000 per affected minor for knowing violations and up to $25,000 per affected minor for negligent ones.
Meta's legal arguments
Meta argues the law violates the First Amendment. The complaint says the law "compels social media services like those operated by Plaintiff Meta Platforms, Inc." to organize and present content to minors in the way the State prefers, and calls AB 1709 "California's latest attempt to flout that fundamental principle and appoint the State as the editor, curator, and controller of online speech." It relies on the Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Moody v. NetChoice, which it says gives feeds of third-party content First Amendment protection as the product of a platform's editorial choices.
Meta also argues that Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act preempts the personalized-feed ban, the autoplay ban and the account-deletion requirement. It cites Ninth Circuit decisions, including Doe 1 v. Twitter (2025), for the position that Section 230 bars state laws that attack how an algorithm sorts, arranges and distributes third-party content.
The complaint further argues the bans are overinclusive because they apply to all minors regardless of how long they are online. It says Meta "will soon default minors to a cumulative two-hour time limit on Facebook and Instagram that only parents or guardians can override," and will give minors and parents options to make the default feed non-personalized and to turn off automatic playing of audio and video. Meta says it neither wants nor intends to ban personalized feeds and autoplay for minors "without regard to their (and their parents') individual choices and preferences."
What the state has said
The complaint points to legislative history, the Governor's statements and the Attorney General's record to argue that California intends to enforce the law. It quotes Newsom's September 10 announcement: "Today's legislation makes clear that California will not stand by while unregulated technology puts our children at risk." It also cites an Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis that projected significant ongoing General Fund costs for the state Department of Justice to bring civil enforcement actions against covered platforms. The complaint adds that Bonta "has publicly pursued enforcement against Meta under other laws."
What happens next
Meta asks for declaratory relief, a preliminary and then permanent injunction against enforcement, and attorneys' fees. The complaint was filed nine days before this article's publication date, and the filing reviewed here includes no ruling, schedule or state response. The law is not scheduled to take effect until January 1, 2027.