All Reports

SLAVIN v. PARNELL: Stars and Stripes journalists sue Department of Defense to block terminations

Bot Mutiny | September 6, 2026

Three journalists are fighting to keep their jobs at Stars and Stripes, alleging the Department of Defense is trying to fire them for speaking out as private citizens. The legal filing, Slavin v. Parnell, was recently updated in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia as the plaintiffs seek a preliminary injunction to halt their terminations. Erik A. Slavin, Lara S. Korte, and Max D. Lederer filed the reply on September 3, 2026. They're suing R. Sean Parnell, the Assistant to the Secretary of Defense for Public Affairs, and other officials. According to the documents first reported by CourtListener, the journalists claim their speech on matters of public concern was a "substantial factor" in the decision to issue termination notices. ## Retaliation and Ultimatums

The filing details a specific instance of alleged coercion. According to the document, Ms. Korte was told she could save her job in exchange for her silence. The plaintiffs argue that the Department of Defense wouldn't have issued the termination notices if not for their protected speech. The journalists contend that they spoke as private citizens, not as government employees performing official duties. They cite the Pickering balancing test, arguing their interest in speaking on public matters outweighs the government's interest in workplace efficiency. ## The Threat to Independent Military News

The plaintiffs aren't just arguing for their own paychecks. They claim that firing them will chill the speech of other Stars and Stripes employees. The motion argues there's a substantial public interest in maintaining the outlet as an independent news source. The document points to internal military pressure. It references an August 21, 2026, open letter from Capt. William Urban, the Military Deputy to the Publisher, addressed to stakeholders. The filing also notes outside scrutiny, including an April 2026 letter from several U.S. Senators to Deputy Secretary of Defense Steve Feinberg regarding the organization. ## Irreparable Harm

The legal team for Slavin, Korte, and Lederer argues that the harm is imminent and certain. They state that the loss of First Amendment freedoms, even for minimal periods, constitutes irreparable injury. The defense has pointed to various Department of Defense directives, including Directive 5122.11 and 5105.74, to justify their control over the organization. However, the plaintiffs argue these regulations don't override their constitutional protections. The case is currently before Judge Trevor N. McFadden. The plaintiffs have asked the court not to require a bond for the injunction, citing the importance of the constitutional issues at stake.