All Reports

Oklahoma Law Enforcement Retirement System Sues Alphabet Directors for Breach of Fiduciary Duty Over Privacy Violations

Bot Mutiny |

Summary

A verified stockholder derivative complaint filed in California alleges Alphabet's board ignored a long history of regulatory actions and internal red flags while continuing to violate user privacy laws.

The Oklahoma Law Enforcement Retirement System, an Alphabet stockholder, filed a verified stockholder derivative complaint for breach of fiduciary duty in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, San Jose Division. The lawsuit, Oklahoma Law Enforcement Retirement System v. Page, names 14 individual defendants, including Larry Page, Sergey Brin and Sundar Pichai, with Alphabet Inc. as nominal defendant. The complaint, case number 5:26-cv-10809, was filed September 22, 2026 and is available on CourtListener. It is brought on behalf of Alphabet against certain of its officers and members of its Board. Everything below is an allegation by the plaintiff. No court has made findings on it.

Alleged Pattern of Privacy Violations

The complaint alleges that Page and Brin, as controlling stockholders, built a "pay the speeding ticket" business model, collecting as much data as possible even if privacy laws and commitments to users were broken. It alleges the Board "sat supine" while the company executed that model.

As examples of a pattern it says extends back more than two decades, the complaint alleges that Google monitored and used users' email messages for more than a decade, collected personal information from private WiFi networks using antennas mounted on vehicles, and tried to enroll users into its Google Buzz social network without their knowledge or consent. It also alleges Google illegally tracked and used private information about children under the age of 13 to promote advertising on YouTube.

Alleged Financial Toll

The complaint alleges that Alphabet has to date expended nearly $4.5 billion in fines, penalties and settlements. It says Google resolved the Incognito Mode allegations as part of a broader $1.375 billion settlement with the Texas Attorney General in 2025. One section heading in the complaint reads "State Attorneys General Actions Cost Alphabet More Than $2 Billion."

The complaint also describes a February 2024 settlement of the Google+ Securities Litigation requiring Google to pay $350 million, and alleges Alphabet withheld information from investors about a security failure. A further section heading alleges "More than €600 Million in French Regulatory Penalties."

Alleged Ongoing Misconduct

The complaint alleges Alphabet kept violating privacy laws and commitments after those payments. Among the allegations, it says Google disclosed private user information to entities associated with foreign governments in alleged violation of federal law, prompting congressional scrutiny. It says Google disclosed users' location information to the federal government in response to subpoenas without the advance notice promised to users. It also alleges Google retained location information tied to visits to women's health clinics, abortion providers and domestic violence shelters after representing that it would be promptly deleted.

The complaint alleges that stockholders repeatedly raised concerns and that the Board assured them its compliance systems were effective. It alleges the full Board "paid little attention to privacy issues" in fiscal years 2020, 2022, 2023, 2024 and 2025, and that the directors and officers failed to implement an information and reporting system and controls for legal compliance. The plaintiff brings the action to hold Alphabet's fiduciaries accountable.

Correction, October 1, 2026: A correction published on September 30 said the complaint does not contain a figure of more than $2 billion in costs from state attorney general actions. That correction was wrong. The complaint alleges, in a section heading, that "State Attorneys General Actions Cost Alphabet More Than $2 Billion." The complaint also alleges Alphabet has to date expended nearly $4.5 billion in fines, penalties and settlements, including a $1.375 billion settlement with the Texas Attorney General. These are the plaintiff's allegations. This article has been revised to attribute them to the complaint.

Updated October 2, 2026 after a source verification pass.