All Reports

U.S. District Court Excludes Expert Testimony After AI Agent Prompts Withheld in Flexport v. Freightmate AI

Bot Mutiny |

Summary

A federal judge has barred expert testimony regarding AI-driven data extraction after the defense failed to disclose the specific prompts generated by a 2026 AI agent to conduct the experiment.

Judge Rita F. Lin of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California signed an order on pretrial matters on September 18, 2026 in Flexport, Inc. v. Freightmate AI, Inc. The order rules on Flexport's motions in limine. It grants Motion in Limine No. 4 in part and excludes testimony about one experiment from Armstrong, an expert for Freightmate, because the defendants did not disclose the prompts an AI agent sent to GPT-4o. The order is Document 285 on the CourtListener docket.

The Experiment

Armstrong used Chat GPT-4o, which the court says corresponds to the model available to Freightmate in July 2024, to ingest a sample of the shipping documents at issue. The order says he found the model extracted the documents without significant prompt engineering with more than 74% accuracy under strict measures and more than 85% accuracy under a "tiered" metric commonly used in the industry. Flexport argued the testimony should be excluded because Armstrong used a 2026 AI agent, Claude Sonnet 4.5, to tell GPT-4o to extract the data. The order says the agent provided the prompts and the 33-field schema to GPT-4o and then compared the results to the original documents.

The Missing Prompts

The court did not reject the use of an AI agent as such. It wrote that using an electronic tool for menial tasks that can be independently verified would not normally make an experiment unreliable, any more than using a human assistant would. The problem was disclosure. The defendants' opposition represented that Armstrong had produced the "verbatim extraction prompts" and that "Flexport was free to re-run the experiment." At the final pretrial conference, Flexport pointed out that Armstrong had not disclosed the prompts sent from the AI agent to GPT-4o. The court said the parties' letters corroborated this and that the defendants did not dispute it. Without the prompts, the court wrote, it is impossible to know what the AI agent told GPT-4o to do. It also said a new run might involve the agent sending different prompts, and asked what if the agent gave detailed prompts that made extraction much easier. It compared this to an expert telling a human assistant to run an experiment without knowing the steps the assistant took. The court stated that the defendants, as proponents of the testimony, bear the burden to show it is reliable and helpful to the jury, and that they failed that burden. The motion to exclude Armstrong's testimony as to the experiment was granted. The order denied the rest of the motion, so Armstrong may testify about industry standards for shipping documents and about using AI to extract information from documents in the logistics context.

Zeidman

On Motion in Limine No. 5, the court granted the motion in part. Zeidman may not opine on what trade secret law is, though he may opine on whether the information at issue is secret or readily ascertainable. The court denied the motion as to his opinion on the lack of literal and low-level non-literal copying, which it found relevant to whether the defendants misappropriated Trade Secret No. 1, Flexport's platform source code. It added that excessive emphasis on the point may raise Rule 403 concerns. It also found his opinion on OpenAI tokens consumed by requests has a sufficient foundation because it relies on the deposition testimony of Freightmate's CTO.

Size, Ill Will and the Withdrawn Claim

The court granted Motion in Limine No. 1 in part. No one may refer to the case as a "David and Goliath" dispute or as a larger company bullying a startup, because that is not relevant and would be more unfairly prejudicial than probative. The court declined to exclude all references to size, saying Freightmate's size, stage of development and resources may be relevant to liability and damages. On Motion in Limine No. 2, evidence bearing only on Flexport's motive to sue is excluded. Evidence that higher-ups at Flexport bear animosity toward Freightmate could be highly relevant to witness bias and credibility for certain Flexport employees, but the court said it would assess objections witness by witness. On Motion in Limine No. 3, there may be no references to Flexport's voluntary withdrawal of its copyright claim, and evidence pertaining solely to that claim is excluded. Evidence relating to both that claim and the remaining live claims remains at issue at trial. The case is Flexport, Inc. v. Freightmate AI, Inc., Case No. 25-cv-02500-RFL.

Updated October 2, 2026 after a source verification pass.